Legal Services Offshore blog
Triage a client document dump into a review plan
Turn an unstructured client production into an inventory, a privilege screen, and a review order without opening every file first or losing the chain of custody.

Stop before opening every file
A client document dump often arrives as a link to a folder with thousands of files, mixed formats, and no index. The instinct is to start reading, but that produces fatigue and inconsistent notes. The first task is to preserve the collection as received and create an inventory. Record the delivery date, the source, the total size, the file count, and the hash or transfer record if the firm uses one. That record protects the chain of custody before anyone edits or reorganizes the material.
Work from a copy, never from the only delivered set. Capture the folder structure as it arrived, because the structure itself may carry meaning about custodians or dates. Do not rename files in the working copy until the inventory is complete. If the client delivered through a link that will expire, download the material to the approved repository and record the download time. A triage plan built on a partial download will miss the files that matter most.
Inventory by custodian and date range
The inventory should answer who created the material, when, and in what format. Extract the available metadata without altering it, and record where the metadata is missing. Group files by custodian and by date range so the team can see the shape of the collection. A dump with a clear date gap may indicate that a device or mailbox was omitted. A dump dominated by one custodian may indicate that others were not collected.
Do not assume that a folder name identifies the custodian. A shared drive may contain files from several people, and a personal folder may contain forwarded material. Where the custodian is unclear, record the uncertainty and route it to the client contact. The inventory should also flag file types that need special handling, such as spreadsheets with formulas, email containers, images, and compressed archives. These formats often hide content that a simple page count will miss.
Separate privileged material early
Privilege review is a legal judgment, but the preparer can build a screen that keeps likely privileged material out of the general review flow. Look for communications with counsel, drafts prepared for legal advice, and documents marked as privileged or confidential. Route those to the attorney rather than deciding whether privilege applies. Record the basis for the flag and the reviewer who will decide.
A privilege screen should be over-inclusive at the start, because it is easier to release a document later than to unsee privileged material. Keep the flagged items in a separate queue with their own log. Do not describe the contents of a flagged document in a shared note. If a document is both responsive and potentially privileged, record the responsiveness facts without summarizing the legal advice. The attorney decides whether to withhold, produce, or log the item.
Group by issue, not by folder name
The client's folder structure reflects how the client stored files, not how the matter is analyzed. After the inventory, group the material by the issues in the review plan. A file can belong to more than one issue, so record the primary group and any secondary group rather than forcing a single choice. This grouping helps the reviewer see whether an issue has enough material or whether a collection gap remains.
Issue grouping should be provisional until the attorney confirms the review scope. Write the grouping rule in the plan so a second preparer can apply it consistently. If a file does not fit any issue, put it in an unclassified queue rather than inventing a category. The unclassified queue is often where the most important document sits, because it did not match the team's assumptions. Review that queue with the attorney before closing the inventory.
Set a review order with reasons
Not every document needs the same attention, and the review order should reflect risk and deadline. Start with the material tied to the earliest deadline, the largest exposure, or the central factual question. Record why each group is in that position so the order can be defended if priorities change. A review plan that says first batch and second batch without reasons is hard to adjust when new information arrives.
Use a simple priority scheme with definitions. For example, priority one might be documents that could change a filing position, priority two might be documents needed for a witness preparation, and priority three might be background. The attorney should approve the scheme. The preparer can then move material through the queue without repeatedly asking what matters most. Review the order at the end of each batch and record any change with its reason.
Record duplicates and near-duplicates
Document dumps contain duplicates, and treating every copy as a separate review item wastes time. Use a hash or a reliable deduplication tool to identify exact duplicates, then record the duplicate group and the custodian for each copy. Do not delete the duplicates from the preserved set. The review copy can point to one representative, but the inventory should preserve the fact that multiple copies existed.
Near-duplicates are harder because a later version may contain a critical edit. Compare the metadata and the visible content before treating two files as the same. Record the version relationship and which copy the reviewer should read. If the tool cannot compare the files reliably, flag the pair for manual review. A deduplication decision that hides a changed paragraph is worse than the time saved.
Hand off a plan with open questions
The triage handoff should include the inventory, the privilege screen, the issue map, the review order, and a list of open questions. Each open question should name the missing information, the person expected to supply it, and the effect on the review. A question about a missing custodian is different from a question about a corrupted file, and the plan should distinguish them. The attorney can then decide what to do next without reading the entire inventory.
Before handoff, confirm that the file counts match the source and that the working copy is stored in the approved location. Run a spot check on a sample of files to confirm that the inventory metadata is accurate. If the client delivered a supplemental collection, add it as a new batch with its own date rather than merging it silently into the first. The plan is a living document, and each version should show what changed and who approved the change.